Antonio`s New York Style Pizza in St. Augustine

Good pizza..

Great place to visit and eat! Wonderful prices and exceptional food.

I'm at Antonio's as we speak enjoying their awesome pizza! The servers are always really nice and fast to bring out your food and drinks. It's a delicious, charming little place, easily affordable and the best deal on the beach.

Decent prices. Friendly service. Ok pizza.

Awesome food and amazing and attentive staff. Just really small for the amount of traffic. But, the place is definitely amazing

Possibly the best pizza I've ever had.

Awesome food, will be back

I got the white pizza add tomato and broccoli. It was delicious, fresh veggies, loads of cheese and super flavorful. Boyfriend got manicotti dinner which was a 12 inch dinner plate FULL. Price was very good also. Highly impressed!

Love the taste, perfect crust, sauce and cheese! Must get the 20 inch for the family

Great pizza and lunch special

Had a large pizza today half cheese and mushrooms onions ground beef it was nasty the beef was nasty don't waist your time there pizza always soggy in the middle long time resident

Perfect pepperoni pizza, sauce was true New York style, crust was seasoned and was awesome. I will definitely be going here for my weekly pizza

Amazing service and food.

Loved the food and service but the address hasn't been updated for 10yrs according to a staff member. Made for a little bit of a confusing drive.

Love there awesome New York Pizza. Try some shrimp on it!! So incredible. The best I ever had

Worst pizza ever $30 for 3 slices of paper soaked in grease, wouldn’t give a discount because we forced the crust down our throats from starvation

Best pizza love it! Thank you guys.

Good pizza and great service.

The pizza is good, just make sure if you do alterations to any pizza that they actually understand. We ordered a supreme with no olives and still received olives, they were just hidden in the toppings. But still a pretty good pizza all around.

Homemade sauce and dough makes this my "go-to" pizzeria in St Augustine Beach! One of the best tasting pizzas we have had since moving from New York.

I had to come back from NYC to Florida to get some New York style pizza! Hand tossed dough! Amazing pepperoni! Get it hot!

Great spot to get classic pizza in St. Augustine. It’s located adjacent to the new Embassy Suites Resort. The prices are relatively reasonable and the pizza is excellent. They offer sub sandwiches and other Italian fare as well.

The pizza was good except there was a hair on it. When I brought this to the attention of the young lady who brought it to the table she picked up the hair and proceeded to play "clues" as she tried to figure out who the hair belonged to. No apology, no money off of our bill. She offered to make another pizza.... which meant another 30-45 minute wait. Please wear a hair net. It's the least you can do.

Only been here twice while on vacation, I really liked it both times.

There are two Antonio’s. The one I’m reviewing is the one next to Rita’s. Google only shows location 2. Had the Gyro, loved it. They make there own bread, so it’s like having a thin pizza crust instead of a pita. Makes a great Gyro. They can make thicker pizzasIf you would like. We are from NY but not crazy about foldable pizza. Foldable is ok if your intending to mail your pizza. Will be back for a Custom pie.

Great food and people who work there

I ordered a pizza at 8:30 pm-gave them my phone number and address. They said it would be 30 minutes. They did not call me to say they couldn’t find the address. When I called there at 9:45, no one answered and the voicemail wasn’t accepting messages. No pizza last night. Their food must be great because their service stinks.

In town for one night and called another pizza place and they were closed. I then called antonios pizza and soo happy I did! Great Thin folding NY style pizza!

Great service amd truly the best pizza I have ever had.

Literally the worst pizza I've ever had in my life.

Pizza was different in taste from the other places in town, which I liked. Restaurant was dirty (dining room) from the night before (I was the first customer if the day).

I lived in Brooklyn for 7 years. The pizza is definitely not not new york style pizza. It's more like cicis pizza. Hardly any cheese on it. It's junk pizza. I will not go back.

Just walking on the fragrance of garlic and a pizza baking was a so warm and welcoming. it is very small, but the pizza was delicious and also came out quickly. The service was excellent. We will be going back next time we are in st. Augustine..

Good New York style pizza. Nice thin crust with a crunchy, chewy edge. Sauce very good. Flavorful cheese. Nice cheap dining option on the beach.

Nice little place to get a bite to eat. Right next to it is an ice cream place. It looked good even though we didn't get to try it this time.

This was delicious pizza. It was delivered before the destinated time. Staff was great.

Had lunch here. The gyro was huge. Perfect for two. Hot, tasty, great flavor. Great service. Highly recommend. Took a pizza home to snack on, also very good.

Best pizza in St. Augustine and we've tried em all.

Good pizza conveniently located near the beach for lunch! They have a cheap lunch special too!

Well we were on the beach and just decided why not? We were hungry but as you can by the picture. The pizza is so good it barely made it long enough to take a picture. Friendly service, clean bathroom, and good pizza. Definitely will try other items when back in this area.

Very nice Pizza, 20 inch 17 Dollar, very tasty

Pretty good pizza. The restaurant is very small but smells amazing. The wait staff was friendly and knowledgeable. They do not serve alcohol.

This is the second time I've been to this location. This is New York style pizza, the prices are so reasonable as well. Anytime I I am in st. Augustine Beach Florida I will definitely return here.

Antonio's Pizza is New York style as said in title. I left a photo below of what a New York style pizza from them looks like. I gave them a 3 star because I've been there twice and each time it had some what of a gloom atmosphere, most the employees were dead inside sounding. I even asked a girl at the front counter about the desk set up( It's a square in the wall like a food truck) "hey, so what happens if someone order something that's bigger than this hole?" And she looked at me but did not give me the time of day to have a convo or even a reply. I was just trying to start up friendly convo so idk. It was good enough for me to go back though.

Came to St Augustine for my boyfriend birthday...went to Antonio's...best pizza we ever had 5star

Best place for pizza on Anastasia Island. Very low key atmosphere if you're dinning in.

Great pizza, great salad, great service! Authentic thin crust New York style pizza... homemade dough.... homemade sauce.......delish!!! Prices reasonable. If you're dining in beware seating is limited but because service is so fast tables do free up quickly.

This pizza is the best 5 out of 5 best pizza I've ever had

Worth the wait. Their pizza is some of the best New York style I've had.

Really good pizza. We ordered and picked up within 20 mins. It was ready when they said it would be. Topping portions were plentiful. Definitely recommend.